I'm so torn.
The banana pudding B brought home for me a few weeks ago was like a 4++! But the cupcakes I've tried have all been solid 3 star quality.
The cupcakes were too dry and the buttercream frosting was just OK. I like my cupcakes to taste really dense and moist. And the buttercream should be rich but not too fatty or sugary tasting. Magnolia cupcakes just didn't do it for me.
I wish I could give a separate rating for just the banana pudding.
Light, fluffy and yet still rich and creamy.
I would probably eat this every single day if I could.
But it's a bakery, not a banana pudding boutique!
Overall: 3 stars